Structural programs are hard, let’s do training programs
“The least you can do” is the minimum unviable product
January 19, 2024 — January 19, 2024
communicating
cooperation
culture
economics
mind
wonk
Assumed audience:
Anyone who would like to fix things and has a training budget
We’ve all run into this situation: An organisation is doing something bad, suggesting something deep needs to change to fix it, something whose remedy would shake the deep foundations of the organisation, and which there is no appetite to address. So, they mandate a training program.
cf tokenism and table stakes, individual solutions to structural problems.
- Work ‘wellness’ programmes don’t make employees happier
- Implicit bias trainings are used to fight racism, but IAT science is flawed.
- People often limit their creativity by continually adding new features to a design rather than removing existing ones
1 References
Boot, LaMontagne, and Madsen. 2024. “Fifty Years of Research on Psychosocial Working Conditions and Health: From Promise to Practice.” Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health.
FitzGerald, Martin, Berner, et al. 2019. “Interventions Designed to Reduce Implicit Prejudices and Implicit Stereotypes in Real World Contexts: A Systematic Review.” BMC Psychology.
Fleming. 2024. “Employee Well-Being Outcomes from Individual-Level Mental Health Interventions: Cross-Sectional Evidence from the United Kingdom.” Industrial Relations Journal.
Gawronski. 2019. “Six Lessons for a Cogent Science of Implicit Bias and Its Criticism.” Perspectives on Psychological Science.
Greenwald, Dasgupta, Dovidio, et al. 2022. “Implicit-Bias Remedies: Treating Discriminatory Bias as a Public-Health Problem.” Psychological Science in the Public Interest: A Journal of the American Psychological Society.
Oliver. 2024. “David Oliver: Work wellness programmes aren’t the key to improving NHS morale or retention.” BMJ (Clinical research ed.).
Rae, Provan, Weber, et al. 2018. “Safety Clutter: The Accumulation and Persistence of ‘Safety’ Work That Does Not Contribute to Operational Safety.” Policy and Practice in Health and Safety.
Terry. 2024. “Research Findings Journalists Cannot Resist: A Tale of Three Mental Health and Well-Being Studies.” American Journal of Health Promotion.
Young, Elgee, Chow, et al. n.d. “A Systematic Review of Cognitive Behavioral and Mindfulness-Based Interventions for White-Collar Worker Mental Well-Being in Business Environments.” Mental Health Science.